#272: A Scottish Soldier by Andy Stewart

Peak Month: February 1961
10 weeks on Vancouver’s CKWX chart
Peak Position #1
Peak Position on Billboard Hot 100 ~ #69
YouTube: “A Scottish Soldier
Lyrics: “A Scottish Soldier

The use of tartan patriotism and stereotypical Scottish humor goes back to Sir Harry Lauder and music hall songs at the turn of the 20th Century. In the 1960s, this genre was showcased by the entertainer Andy Stewart. Born in Glasgow, Scotland, in 1933, Stewart enjoyed a number of international hits including “Donald Where’s Your Troosers?” and “A Scottish Soldier”. In his school years he appeared in numbers of acting roles and eventually studied acting in college. Out of college he was immediately scouted to perform in dramas, variety shows and stand-up comedy. After opening for Billy Eckstine in Manchester, Stewart appeared across Scotland and England as a comedy impressionist with James Stewart, James Cagney, Elvis Presley, Petula Clark, Charles Laughton, Perry Como, Johnnie Ray, Al Jolson and Louis Armstrong among his repertoire. One of his most popular routines was to perform the well-known and peculiarly Scottish song, “Ye Cannae Shove yer Granny Aff a Bus”, in the voices of American stars like Jolson or Armstrong.

He was  also known as the compere of BBC Scotland TV show The White Heather Club that was shown each New Year’s Eve between 1957 and 1968. On July 3, 1958, Stewart appeared before Her Majesty The Queen and The Duke of Edinburgh at a theatre in Edinburgh.

In 1959, Andy Stewart signed his first recording contract with the small British label of Top Rank. His first recording, “Donald Where’s Your Troosers?” was a light-hearted, almost throwaway track, during a recording session with his White Heather Group. However Top Rank considered it worth releasing as a 45 RPM single.

For Andy’s next single release, he chose “A Scottish Soldier”.

A Scottish Soldier by Andy Stewart

Andy had based the song on an old pipe-tune, “The Green Hills of Tyrol.” He’d first heard the tune as a boy when the family visited Braemar Highland Games. The song had been growing in popularity following repeat performances on The White Heather Club. Stewart recalls, “I got an idea for the lyric for the song. It was a story about a Scottish soldier who finds himself in a far land, his soldiering days are over and the call of his own country takes him back for his final resting to Scotland. And I sat down and the words just came to me: “there was a soldier, a Scottish soldier…” Though he got a backlash from some Scottish traditionalists who believed he’d ruined “The Green Hills of Tyrol” by putting words to the tune, Stewart knew the melody was actually a traditional Swiss air heard in Sardinia and borrowed by a Scottish Pipe-Major during the Crimean War.

Tyrol is a region in the Alps in northern Italy and western Austria. The song is about a dying Scottish soldier, wishing to return to the hills of his homeland rather than die in the Tyrol. In the lyrics a piper plays as the Scottish soldier returns home to a Scottish hillside. The bugles cease and the soldier rests in peace. The tune was adopted as the entrance theme of professional wrestler Rowdy Roddy Piper, who wore a kilt and carried a bagpipe into the wrestling ring.

“A Scottish Soldier” spent 40 weeks on the UK charts, peaking at #19, and became the fourth biggest single for the year 1961 in the UK. The song also became the third biggest seller for sheet music in 1961 in the UK. In Canada it happened that “A Scottish Soldier” was the first single to chart in the country, followed shortly after by “Donald Where’s Your Troosers?”

“A Scottish Soldier” peaked at #1 in Vancouver (BC), Toronto, Ottawa (ON), and Calgary (AB), #2 in Cleveland, #6 in Youngstown (OH), #8 in Grand Rapids (MI), and #9 in Montreal. In Australia, “A Scottish Soldier” peaked at #1 in Melbourne and Sydney, and #6 in Brisbane and Newcastle.

In 1962 Andy Stewart started his own publishing company, Lochside Music Publishing Company Ltd to administer his songs as his catalogue increased and putting lyrics to tunes became his chosen method of composing – providing a magic formula for the “hits.”

In 1963 Stewart went on a world tour that included stops at the Sydney Opera House in Sydney, Australia, Carnegie Hall in New York City, stops in Hong Kong, Canada, New Zealand, Tasmania, South Africa, Southern Rhodesia and other countries. In the course of his career Stewart appeared in many TV specials and shows including television shows over the years including: Andy Stewart in London (1962), The Saturday Show (1962), The Andy Stewart Show (1963), The Man Behind the Star (1965), A Song for Scotland (1966), The London Palladium Show (1967), The Scottish Minstrel (1967), Stewart Style (1969), The Andy Stewart Show (1970), Stars on Sunday (1971), The Andy Stewart Show (1975) and Andy’s Party (1978).

Into the 1980’s Andy Stewart was becoming a symbol of the “Old Scotland” for many Scots who were embarrassed by perpetual images of haggis, Hogmanay and kilts as representing Scotland. He spent much of the decade touring internationally. But in 1989 “Donald Where’s Your Troosers?” was reissued and climbed to #4 on the UK charts. Stewart was back in fashion, including in Scotland.

During his career Andy Stewart released 26 studio albums and one live album. Plagued with ill-health most of his adult life, especially due to high cholesterol levels, Stewart died at the age of 60 in 1993. Since his death over a have a dozen compilation CD releases have been made available to showcase the work of one of Scotland’s greatest comics.

October 20, 2021
Ray McGinnis

Gordon Irving, “Obituary: Andy Stewart,” Independent, UK, October 12, 1993
Andy Stewart ~ An Illustrated Record ~ Fansite (bio)
British Music Hall ~ Wikipedia
Isle of Skye visitscotland.com
Sheep Taking a Stroll on the Isle of Skye, Scotland,” insight guides.com, January 18, 2016.
Fabulous Forty,” CKWX 1130 AM, Vancouver, BC, February 25, 1961.

For more song reviews visit the Countdown.

2 responses to “A Scottish Soldier by Andy Stewart”

  1. Judy says:

    Oh, my what an innocent time that was, when a song like that could be #1.

  2. Robert Michael Genders says:

    Shows was a true Scott was . The feeling to be Scottish

Leave a Reply

Sign Up For Our Newsletter